10 Best Consignment Shops in Indiana!

In the mood for some shopping but don’t want to overspend? When was the last time you browsed a consignment shop? If you’re due, we have you covered. From the ornate home decor at Consigned by Design to the eclectic collections at Hip Hop Consignment Shop, you’ll love these 10 best consignment shops in Indiana.

Consigned by Design, Indianapolis, IN

Consigned by Design is the ultimate place to upgrade your home’s style. This expansive home consignment shop has an excellent selection of furniture, decor, and paints, as well as apparel.

Selective Seconds Consignment, Greenwood, IN

Consignment shops can be packed with quality, and no one knows that better than Selective Seconds Consignment. This Greenwood shop has a variety of apparel and fashion accessories as well as housewares, home decor, and more.

Amanda’s Exchange, Carmel, IN

Amanda’s Exchange will have both you and your home looking spectacular. This Carmel shop offers consignment for both fashion and the home, so stop in to update your look without spending more than you have to.

2 Chicks Resale and Consignment, Highland, IN

It started with just two chicks who loved giving items a second chance, and now it’s a favorite shopping destination. Located in Highland, 2 Chicks Resale and Consignment is a fantastic place to find a wide variety of odds and ends.

The Branded Exchange, Greenfield, IN

Looking for quality and brands you trust? Head to The Branded Exchange. This Greenfield shop specifically offers consignment for apparel from upscale brands, so you always know you’ll find something that’s worth a second look.

Eliza’s Consignment Boutique, Crawfordsville, IN

If you’re in the Crawfordsville area and you haven’t yet visited Eliza’s Consignment Boutique, it’s time to pop in. Explore this fun local boutique to discover pre-owned clothes, jewelry, and accessories you’ll love.

Classic Collections Consignment Shop, New Castle, IN

In need of a wardrobe refresh? Check out New Castle’s popular Classic Collections Consignment Shop. This local store specializes in women’s clothing, so bring your wallet and your energy so you can shop ‘til you drop.

Hip Hop Consignment Shop, Decatur, IN

Hip Hop Consignment Shop is that store that truly has everything. The bulk of the store is apparel, but it also has an abundant collection of home goods, shoes, and more. Make time for a visit and you’ll be glad you did.

Sugar Creek Boutique and Consignments, New Palestine, IN

You don’t have to compromise your style to save on a wardrobe update - at least, not when you shop at Sugar Creek Boutique and Consignments. This New Palestine shop has all the latest trends and styles that won’t break your wallet.

Simply Chic, Noblesville, IN

Simply Chic is the best place in Noblesville to find beautiful and up-to-date fashions on a budget. Check it out to find treasures in a variety of styles all at your fingertips.

Share your favorites!
Indiana Search
Find Consignment Shops Near You
Select a Indiana town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Ohio County
Vanderburgh County