Change State
  1. Select a State
  2. Indiana

10 Best Cookie Places in Indiana!

It’s time for dessert, and the great state of Indiana hosts some of the best cookie spots around, and here is an expert list of the top 10. So the next time you have a hankering for something sweet, be sure to check out one of the spots below and you won’t be disappointed!

Share your favorites in the comments below!

Baked Bloomington, IN

From the comfy setup to the late hours and delivery option, you’ll always love indulging in your favorite cookie(s) from this cookie spot! Here, you can pick from a wide selection of doughs, mix-ins, and toppings, with something delicious for everyone.

Sweet Escape Cake Company - Indianapolis, IN

This full service custom bakery is the place to go when you’re in the mood for something special. They carry cookies, cupcakes, and other confectionary creations for any and all occasions. Whether it's for a celebration or some afternoon pick me up, Sweet Escape is the place to go.

Schmidt Bakery - Batesville, IN

If you’re a fan of freshly-baked goods, then Schmidt Bakery in Batesville is the place for you! Home to the one and only yearly event ‘Cherry Thing-A-Ling’, this is an old-fashioned bakery where everything is made freshly daily. And if you’re in the mood for a hot cup of joe, Schmidt’s can provide that too.

Ahlemeyer Bakery - Columbus, IN

Family-owned and operated since 1989, Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery will tantalize your taste buds like never before! Specializing in cookies, sweet rolls, and breads, they’ve also got you covered if you’re looking for a classic Indiana treat.

William’s Bakery - Clarksville, IN

You’ll be spoilt for choice at William’s Bakery, as you try and eat your way through their menu, devouring their delicious cookies instantly. There’s something for everyone here, even if you’re short on time.

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen - New Albany, IN

At the Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen, they’ve got your sweet tooth covered! From freshly-churned ice creams to pies, out of this world cookies, and more. Everything is handcrafted in house, especially their variety of cookies. So you know it’s coming fresh!

Ragamuffin Bakery + Coffee - South Bend, IN

At The Ragamuffin, they are about bringing people together through delicious cookies. From specialty flavors to freshly brewed coffee, everyone will fall in love with a tasty treat here.

Blondie's Cookies, Indianapolis, IN

If you're in the Indianapolis area, you must make a stop at Blondie's Cookies. This small shop has made quite a splash, as it was even featured on an episode of Shark Tank! They bake their cookies fresh every day to ensure that you get the best of the best! Enjoy these delicious treats in the store and take some home to share with your friends and family.

No Label At The Table - Carmel, IN

At NoLabel, they are completely gluten and dairy free, so those who are sensitive to certain foods can be assured they’re accounted for here. The kitchen specializes in a range of desserts, but their ginger cookies are second to none. Grab yourself a few and let your tastebuds run wild.

Boyden’s Southside Bakery - Indianapolis, IN

The appeal of Boyden’s Southside Bakery is certainly in its simplicity- this no-frills sweet cookie spot has got you covered if you’re looking for cookies, complimentary coffee and pastries. With artfully decorated classic cookies to some local favorite flavors, you’ll have many to choose from.

This text was created by the author with the assistance of GPT-3, a large-scale language generation model developed by OpenAI. The author reviewed, edited, and revised the draft language to their satisfaction and is fully responsible for the content of this publication.

Share your favorites!
Indiana Search
Find the Best Cookies Near You
(Use Your Current Location)
Select a Indiana town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Adams County
  • Berne
  • Decatur
  • Geneva
  • Linn Grove
  • Monroe
  • Pleasant Mills
  • Preble
Allen County
  • Arcola
  • Fort Wayne
  • Grabill
  • Harlan
  • Hoagland
  • Huntertown
  • Leo
  • Leo Cedarville
  • Monroeville
  • New Haven
  • Spencerville
  • Woodburn
  • Yoder
  • Zanesville
Bartholomew County
  • Clifford
  • Columbus
  • Elizabethtown
  • Grammer
  • Hartsville
  • Hope
  • Jonesville
  • Taylorsville
Benton County
  • Ambia
  • Boswell
  • Earl Park
  • Fowler
  • Otterbein
  • Oxford
  • Talbot
  • Templeton
Blackford County
  • Hartford City
  • Montpelier
Boone County
  • Advance
  • Jamestown
  • Lebanon
  • Thorntown
  • Whitestown
  • Zionsville
Brown County
  • Helmsburg
  • Nashville
Carroll County
  • Bringhurst
  • Burlington
  • Burrows
  • Camden
  • Cutler
  • Delphi
  • Flora
  • Rockfield
  • Yeoman
Cass County
  • Galveston
  • Lake Cicott
  • Logansport
  • Lucerne
  • New Waverly
  • Onward
  • Royal Center
  • Twelve Mile
  • Walton
  • Young America
Clark County
  • Bethlehem
  • Borden
  • Charlestown
  • Clarksville
  • Henryville
  • Jeffersonville
  • Marysville
  • Memphis
  • Nabb
  • New Washington
  • Otisco
  • Sellersburg
  • Starlight
  • Utica
Clay County
  • Bowling Green
  • Brazil
  • Carbon
  • Centerpoint
  • Clay City
  • Coalmont
  • Cory
  • Harmony
  • Knightsville
  • Staunton
Clinton County
  • Colfax
  • Forest
  • Frankfort
  • Kirklin
  • Michigantown
  • Mulberry
  • Rossville
  • Sedalia
Crawford County
  • Eckerty
  • English
  • Grantsburg
  • Leavenworth
  • Marengo
  • Milltown
  • Sulphur
  • Taswell
Daviess County
  • Cannelburg
  • Elnora
  • Montgomery
  • Odon
  • Plainville
  • Washington
De Kalb County
  • Ashley
  • Auburn
  • Butler
  • Corunna
  • Garrett
  • Saint Joe
  • Waterloo
Dearborn County
  • Aurora
  • Bright
  • Dillsboro
  • Greendale
  • Guilford
  • Lawrenceburg
  • Moores Hill
  • West Harrison
Decatur County
  • Clarksburg
  • Greensburg
  • Millhousen
  • New Point
  • Saint Paul
  • Westport
Delaware County
  • Albany
  • Daleville
  • Eaton
  • Gaston
  • Muncie
  • Oakville
  • Selma
  • Yorktown
Dubois County
  • Birdseye
  • Celestine
  • Dubois
  • Ferdinand
  • Holland
  • Huntingburg
  • Ireland
  • Jasper
  • Saint Anthony
  • Schnellville
Elkhart County
  • Bristol
  • Elkhart
  • Goshen
  • Middlebury
  • Millersburg
  • Nappanee
  • New Paris
  • Wakarusa
Fayette County
  • Bentonville
  • Connersville
  • Glenwood
Floyd County
  • Floyds Knobs
  • Georgetown
  • Greenville
  • Mount Saint Francis
  • New Albany
Fountain County
  • Attica
  • Covington
  • Hillsboro
  • Kingman
  • Mellott
  • Newtown
  • Veedersburg
  • Wallace
Franklin County
  • Bath
  • Brookville
  • Cedar Grove
  • Laurel
  • Metamora
  • New Trenton
  • Oldenburg
Fulton County
  • Akron
  • Athens
  • Delong
  • Fulton
  • Grass Creek
  • Kewanna
  • Leiters Ford
  • Rochester
Gibson County
  • Buckskin
  • Fort Branch
  • Francisco
  • Haubstadt
  • Hazleton
  • Mackey
  • Oakland City
  • Owensville
  • Patoka
  • Princeton
  • Somerville
Grant County
  • Fairmount
  • Fowlerton
  • Gas City
  • Jonesboro
  • Marion
  • Matthews
  • Swayzee
  • Sweetser
  • Upland
  • Van Buren
Greene County
  • Bloomfield
  • Jasonville
  • Koleen
  • Linton
  • Lyons
  • Midland
  • Newberry
  • Owensburg
  • Scotland
  • Solsberry
  • Switz City
  • Worthington
Hamilton County
  • Arcadia
  • Atlanta
  • Carmel
  • Cicero
  • Fishers
  • Noblesville
  • Sheridan
  • Westfield
Hancock County
  • Charlottesville
  • Finly
  • Fortville
  • Greenfield
  • Maxwell
  • Mc Cordsville
  • New Palestine
  • Wilkinson
Harrison County
  • Bradford
  • Central
  • Corydon
  • Crandall
  • Depauw
  • Elizabeth
  • Laconia
  • Lanesville
  • Mauckport
  • New Middletown
  • New Salisbury
  • Palmyra
  • Ramsey
Hendricks County
  • Amo
  • Avon
  • Brownsburg
  • Clayton
  • Danville
  • Lizton
  • North Salem
  • Pittsboro
  • Plainfield
  • Stilesville
Henry County
  • Dunreith
  • Greensboro
  • Kennard
  • Knightstown
  • Lewisville
  • Middletown
  • Mooreland
  • Mount Summit
  • New Castle
  • New Lisbon
  • Shirley
  • Spiceland
  • Springport
  • Straughn
  • Sulphur Springs
Howard County
  • Greentown
  • Hemlock
  • Kokomo
  • Oakford
  • Russiaville
  • West Middleton
Huntington County
  • Andrews
  • Bippus
  • Huntington
  • Roanoke
  • Warren
Jackson County
  • Brownstown
  • Cortland
  • Crothersville
  • Freetown
  • Kurtz
  • Medora
  • Norman
  • Seymour
  • Vallonia
Jasper County
  • Demotte
  • Fair Oaks
  • Remington
  • Rensselaer
  • Tefft
  • Wheatfield
Jay County
  • Bryant
  • Dunkirk
  • Pennville
  • Portland
  • Redkey
  • Salamonia
Jefferson County
  • Canaan
  • Deputy
  • Dupont
  • Hanover
  • Madison
Jennings County
  • Butlerville
  • Commiskey
  • Hayden
  • North Vernon
  • Paris Crossing
  • Scipio
  • Vernon
Johnson County
  • Bargersville
  • Edinburgh
  • Franklin
  • Greenwood
  • Needham
  • Nineveh
  • Trafalgar
  • Whiteland
Knox County
  • Bicknell
  • Bruceville
  • Decker
  • Edwardsport
  • Freelandville
  • Monroe City
  • Oaktown
  • Ragsdale
  • Sandborn
  • Vincennes
  • Westphalia
  • Wheatland
Kosciusko County
  • Atwood
  • Burket
  • Claypool
  • Etna Green
  • Leesburg
  • Mentone
  • Milford
  • North Webster
  • Pierceton
  • Silver Lake
  • Syracuse
  • Warsaw
  • Winona Lake
La Porte County
  • Hanna
  • Kingsbury
  • Kingsford Heights
  • La Crosse
  • La Porte
  • Laporte
  • Long Beach
  • Michigan City
  • Mill Creek
  • Rolling Prairie
  • Union Mills
  • Wanatah
  • Westville
LaGrange County
  • Howe
  • LaGrange
  • Mongo
  • Shipshewana
  • South Milford
  • Stroh
  • Topeka
  • Wolcottville
Lake County
  • Cedar Lake
  • Crown Point
  • Dyer
  • East Chicago
  • Gary
  • Griffith
  • Hammond
  • Highland
  • Hobart
  • Lake Station
  • Leroy
  • Lowell
  • Merrillville
  • Miller Beach
  • Munster
  • Saint John
  • Schererville
  • Schneider
  • Shelby
  • Whiting
Lawrence County
  • Avoca
  • Bedford
  • Fort Ritner
  • Heltonville
  • Huron
  • Mitchell
  • Oolitic
  • Springville
  • Tunnelton
  • Williams
Madison County
  • Alexandria
  • Anderson
  • Elwood
  • Frankton
  • Ingalls
  • Lapel
  • Markleville
  • Orestes
  • Pendleton
  • Summitville
Marion County
  • Beech Grove
  • Indianapolis
  • Speedway
  • West Newton
Marshall County
  • Argos
  • Bourbon
  • Bremen
  • Culver
  • Donaldson
  • Lapaz
  • Plymouth
  • Tippecanoe
  • Tyner
Martin County
  • Crane
  • Loogootee
  • Shoals
Miami County
  • Amboy
  • Bunker Hill
  • Converse
  • Deedsville
  • Denver
  • Grissom ARB
  • Macy
  • Mexico
  • Miami
  • Peru
Monroe County
  • Bloomington
  • Clear Creek
  • Ellettsville
  • Harrodsburg
  • Smithville
  • Stanford
  • Stinesville
  • Unionville
Montgomery County
  • Alamo
  • Crawfordsville
  • Darlington
  • Ladoga
  • Linden
  • New Market
  • New Richmond
  • New Ross
  • Waveland
  • Waynetown
  • Wingate
Morgan County
  • Brooklyn
  • Camby
  • Eminence
  • Martinsville
  • Monrovia
  • Mooresville
  • Morgantown
  • Paragon
Newton County
  • Brook
  • Goodland
  • Kentland
  • Lake Village
  • Morocco
  • Mount Ayr
  • Roselawn
  • Sumava Resorts
  • Thayer
Noble County
  • Albion
  • Avilla
  • Cromwell
  • Kendallville
  • Kimmell
  • Laotto
  • Ligonier
  • Rome City
  • Wawaka
  • Wolflake
Ohio County
  • Rising Sun
Orange County
  • French Lick
  • Orleans
  • Paoli
  • West Baden Springs
Owen County
  • Coal City
  • Freedom
  • Gosport
  • Patricksburg
  • Poland
  • Quincy
  • Spencer
Parke County
  • Bellmore
  • Bloomingdale
  • Bridgeton
  • Judson
  • Marshall
  • Mecca
  • Montezuma
  • Rockville
  • Rosedale
Perry County
  • Branchville
  • Bristow
  • Cannelton
  • Derby
  • Leopold
  • Rome
  • Saint Croix
  • Tell City
Pike County
  • Otwell
  • Petersburg
  • Spurgeon
  • Stendal
  • Velpen
  • Winslow
Porter County
  • Beverly Shores
  • Boone Grove
  • Chesterton
  • Hebron
  • Kouts
  • Ogden Dunes
  • Portage
  • Porter
  • Valparaiso
  • Wheeler
Posey County
  • Cynthiana
  • Griffin
  • Mount Vernon
  • New Harmony
  • Poseyville
  • Wadesville
Pulaski County
  • Francesville
  • Medaryville
  • Monterey
  • Star City
  • Winamac
Putnam County
  • Bainbridge
  • Cloverdale
  • Coatesville
  • Fillmore
  • Greencastle
  • Putnamville
  • Reelsville
  • Roachdale
  • Russellville
Randolph County
  • Farmland
  • Losantville
  • Lynn
  • Modoc
  • Parker City
  • Ridgeville
  • Saratoga
  • Union City
  • Winchester
Ripley County
  • Batesville
  • Cross Plains
  • Friendship
  • Holton
  • Milan
  • Morris
  • Napoleon
  • Osgood
  • Pierceville
  • Sunman
  • Versailles
Rush County
  • Arlington
  • Carthage
  • Falmouth
  • Homer
  • Manilla
  • Mays
  • Milroy
  • Rushville
Scott County
  • Austin
  • Lexington
  • Scottsburg
  • Underwood
Shelby County
  • Boggstown
  • Fairland
  • Flat Rock
  • Fountaintown
  • Gwynneville
  • Morristown
  • Shelbyville
  • Waldron
Spencer County
  • Chrisney
  • Dale
  • Evanston
  • Fulda
  • Gentryville
  • Grandview
  • Hatfield
  • Lamar
  • Lincoln City
  • Mariah Hill
  • Richland
  • Rockport
  • Saint Meinrad
  • Santa Claus
  • Troy
St Joseph County
  • Granger
  • Lakeville
  • Mishawaka
  • New Carlisle
  • North Liberty
  • Notre Dame
  • Osceola
  • South Bend
  • Walkerton
  • Wyatt
Starke County
  • Grovertown
  • Hamlet
  • Knox
  • North Judson
  • Ora
  • San Pierre
Steuben County
  • Angola
  • Fremont
  • Hamilton
  • Hudson
  • Orland
  • Pleasant Lake
Sullivan County
  • Carlisle
  • Dugger
  • Fairbanks
  • Farmersburg
  • Graysville
  • Hymera
  • Merom
  • New Lebanon
  • Paxton
  • Shelburn
  • Sullivan
Switzerland County
  • Bennington
  • East Enterprise
  • Florence
  • Patriot
  • Vevay
Tippecanoe County
  • Battle Ground
  • Buck Creek
  • Clarks Hill
  • Dayton
  • Lafayette
  • Montmorenci
  • Romney
  • Stockwell
  • West Lafayette
  • Westpoint
Tipton County
  • Goldsmith
  • Hobbs
  • Kempton
  • Sharpsville
  • Tipton
  • Windfall
Union County
  • Brownsville
  • Liberty
  • West College Corner
Vanderburgh County
  • Evansville
  • Inglefield
Vermillion County
  • Blanford
  • Cayuga
  • Clinton
  • Dana
  • Hillsdale
  • Newport
  • Perrysville
  • Saint Bernice
  • Universal
Vigo County
  • Fontanet
  • Lewis
  • New Goshen
  • Pimento
  • Prairie Creek
  • Prairieton
  • Riley
  • Saint Mary of the Woods
  • Seelyville
  • Shepardsville
  • Terre Haute
  • West Terre Haute
Wabash County
  • La Fontaine
  • Lagro
  • Laketon
  • Liberty Mills
  • North Manchester
  • Roann
  • Servia
  • Somerset
  • Urbana
  • Wabash
Warren County
  • Pine Village
  • State Line
  • West Lebanon
  • Williamsport
Warrick County
  • Boonville
  • Chandler
  • Elberfeld
  • Folsomville
  • Lynnville
  • Newburgh
  • Tennyson
Washington County
  • Campbellsburg
  • Fredericksburg
  • Hardinsburg
  • Little York
  • Pekin
  • Salem
Wayne County
  • Boston
  • Cambridge City
  • Centerville
  • Dublin
  • Economy
  • Fountain City
  • Greens Fork
  • Hagerstown
  • Milton
  • Pershing
  • Richmond
  • Webster
  • Williamsburg
Wells County
  • Bluffton
  • Craigville
  • Keystone
  • Liberty Center
  • Markle
  • Ossian
  • Petroleum
  • Poneto
  • Uniondale
White County
  • Brookston
  • Buffalo
  • Burnettsville
  • Chalmers
  • Idaville
  • Monon
  • Monticello
  • Reynolds
  • Wolcott
Whitley County
  • Churubusco
  • Columbia City
  • Larwill
  • South Whitley

Contact Us

Frequently Asked Questions

Report Incorrect Information

DMCA Policy

© 2023

Some page content

Terms and Conditions of Use | Privacy Policy | Contact Us

Change State
  • Alabama
  • Alaska
  • Arizona
  • Arkansas
  • California
  • Colorado
  • Connecticut
  • Delaware
  • Florida
  • Georgia
  • Hawaii
  • Idaho
  • Illinois
  • Indiana
  • Iowa
  • Kansas
  • Kentucky
  • Louisiana
  • Maine
  • Maryland
  • Massachusetts
  • Michigan
  • Minnesota
  • Mississippi
  • Missouri
  • Montana
  • Nebraska
  • Nevada
  • New Hampshire
  • New Jersey
  • New Mexico
  • New York
  • North Carolina
  • North Dakota
  • Ohio
  • Oklahoma
  • Oregon
  • Pennsylvania
  • Rhode Island
  • South Carolina
  • South Dakota
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • Utah
  • Vermont
  • Virginia
  • Washington
  • West Virginia
  • Wisconsin
  • Wyoming
Select Nearby Town