9 Best Italian Restaurants in Indiana!

In the mood for Italian food? No matter where in Indiana you are, there are outstanding options in your area. From Indianapolis to Valparaiso, you’ll love these 9 Italian restaurants in the Hoosier State.

Mama Carolla’s, Indianapolis, IN

Want a date to remember? Plan for a special evening at Mama Carolla’s. This fabulous destination in Indy is the picture of luxury, with a romantic atmosphere, stellar service, and, of course, amazing food.

Pasto Italiano, Westfield, IN

Pasto Italiano is one of those restaurants where everyone in the area wants to take their guests because it will put a smile on anyone’s face. The tasty food is a welcome treat any day, but be sure to stop in on Wednesdays especially for live music and half-priced bottles of wine.

Zianos Italian Eatery, Fort Wayne, IN

When Fort Wayne wants quality Italian food, they go to Zianos Italian Eatery. This fantastic local restaurant is a local favorite, with weekday specials that are easy on your budget and homemade breadsticks you’ll be hooked on from the first bite.

Little Italy, Dyer, IN

The finest restaurants always start with a genuine passion for great food, and that’s the case at Little Italy in Dyer. This chef-owned restaurant delivers an impeccable venture every time with food that will wow anyone.

Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine, Carmel, IN

If you’re in the Carmel area, Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine is your destination for authenticity and quality. It serves up all your favorite staples from risotto frutti di mare to gnocchi and more.

Carmela’s Restaurant, South Bend, IN

Downtown South Bend is home to one of the area’s culinary treasures, Carmela’s Restaurant. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just treating yourself to a delightful night on the town, Carmela’s is the place to go.

Ciao Bella Ristorante, Schererville, IN

“Ciao Bella” translates to “hello beautiful,” and you’ll be saying that every time you stroll into this Schererville restaurant. The food and the atmosphere are nothing short of beautiful, especially when you mix in one of the restaurant’s fantastic wines too.

La Scala Italian Restaurant, Lafayette, IN

For over 20 years, La Scala Italian Restaurant has been delighting Lafayette with incredible Italian cuisine. This chef-owned restaurant is all about quality, from fresh ingredients to premium cooking, and you can taste it in every bite.

Pesto’s Italian Restaurant, Valparaiso, IN

In Valparaiso, Pesto’s Italian Restaurant is the place to go for Italian food that will leave you feeling full and satisfied. Your taste buds will thank you, whether you opt for the dine-in pizza or pasta or whether you feed your next event with one of the amazing to-go pasta pans.

Share your favorites!
Indiana Search
Find Italian Restaurants Near You
Select a Indiana town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Ohio County
Vanderburgh County