The 10 Best Cake Shops in Indiana!

Who doesn’t love cake? Whether it’s birthday cake, bar mitzvah cake, wedding cake, graduation cake, nothing beats that first sweet bite of a well-prepared cake! Next time you’re planning an event, order something amazing from the 10 best cake shops in Indiana.  

1. Taylor’s Bakery, Fishers and Indianapolis, IN

Taylor’s Bakery is a fourth generation, family owned and operated bakery. In 2013, the bakery celebrated its 100th anniversary! This delicious bakery specializes in made from scratch recipes and can create some of the most unique cakes and designs that one has ever seen! They offer angel food cakes, wedding cakes, and birthday cakes. Each cake is customized based on the customer’s needs, and their birthday cakes are the most popular, with designs like doll cakes, made for the special princess in your life, giant cupcakes, numeral shaped cakes, sheet cakes, shaped cakes, etc. No matter your cake needs, Taylor’s Bakery has it all!

2. Sassie Cakes, Fort Wayne, IN

Sassie Cakes is a custom cake boutique and cupcake parlor which opened in 2014. It’s another that is family owned and operated, committed to providing the highest quality of cakes and exceptional customer service. Whether you desire a traditional fondant cake or a homemade buttercream icing cake, Sassie Cakes’ cakes are custom made and delicious. They also specialize in some unique flavors and fillings: lemon curd, raspberry fruit filling, lemon buttercream, cream cheese, Nutella, and strawberry fruit filling! 

3. Piece of Cake Bakery, Evansville, IN

Piece of Cake Bakery in southern Evansville, Indiana, is a local bakery that specializes in made-from-scratch, delicious, and beautifully-decorated cakes and other goodies. It’s where the happiest birthday cakes in town are! And not only are they the happiest cakes in town, they’re also the most delectable! They also make some of the most mind-blowing cheesecake. Choose from original, blueberry, cherry, or chocolate ganache topped, caramel apple, chocolate covered cherry, turtle or strawberry. You can also choose the layer cheesecakes, which are sandwiched between two layers of cake and iced in one of their delicious, homemade frostings! 

4. Queen Bee Confections and Mansion on Main, Richmond, IN

At Queen Bee Confections and Mansion on Main, owner/operate/baker/decorator Heather Stegner believes that everyone can have their cake and eat it too, even if it means that cake is gluten, grain, dairy, egg, paleo or dye free! The bakery is located inside the beautiful and historic Oliver P. Gaar mansion in Richmond, Indiana. The mansion is as breathtaking as the cakes, and makes it a one of a kind venue. There are dozens of cake options to choose from, as well as icings and fillings! Be sure to order yours today!

5. WildFlour, Valparaiso, IN

It’s about creating desserts and other treats that are as beautiful as they are delicious by using simple, pure, and high-quality ingredients! The shop is warm and inviting, and with each visit it’s as if you’re connecting with old friends. Located in downtown Valparaiso, Indiana, WildFlour was born from a dream and grew with hard work and delicious creations. It’s a small, gourmet bakery that specializes in one of a kind, classical creations.

6. Sugar Daddy’s Cakes and Catering, Bloomington, IN

Whether it’s big or small, Sugar Daddy’s Cakes and Catering can create them all! It’s simple elegance and delectable taste which has made Sugar Daddy’s the most sought after bakery in southern Indiana. There are over 15 different cake flavors to choose from, including banana chocolate chip, orange cream, snicker doodles, pink champagne, amaretto, and more! They also offer unique filling flavors such as chocolate fudge, guava, peach, and many more! Looking for something a little different? Try one of their delicious cheesecakes, push up cake pops, or chocolate cheesecake balls.

7. The Cakehole, New Palestine, IN

You know how sometimes you can see what you need in your head but can’t find someone to create it for you? The Cakehole in New Palestine, Indiana, has you covered! Jovanna is the mastermind behind this amazing place and those amazing creations you won’t find anywhere else but here! It started with making cakes for friends and family, and slowly morphed into a business and a dream. All cakes (including cupcakes) and icings are made from scratch, including flavors such as French vanilla, chocolate coconut, vanilla cookies n’ crème, peppermint, all berry flavors, pumpkin, and turtle!

A post shared by The Cakehole (@the_cakehole) on

8. Betty’s Cake and Candy Shop, Warsaw, IN

This adorable bakery and cake shop has been family owned and operated for over 35 years! They pride themselves on customer satisfaction and taste, and they only use the best of the best buttercream icing which is mixed fresh, daily. The staff is friendly and courteous, and go out of their way to make sure your cake is planned down to the very last detail. Choose from delicious flavors such as German chocolate, cherry chip, classic red velvet, pineapple, or carrot!

9. Confectioneiress, Zionsville, IN

Instead of pulling all-nighters studying for medical exams, co-owner and decorator Mica Gosnell spends her nights creating some of the most unique and delicious cake designs at Confectioneiress in southern Zionsville, Indiana. It’s been said that this is the place to go if you want creative and delicious cakes, and it’s easy to see why once you’ve gotten a glimpse of the scrumptiousness waiting inside! Whether you need a custom cake or a themed cake like “the Little Mermaid” or Marvel’s Action Heroes, Confectioneiress can do it all!

10. Something Blue Bakery, Lafayette, IN

If you should happen to find yourself in need of a great cake for your next event, one that will have your guests asking, “Where can I get one?” the Something Blue Bakery is the place to suggest! The Something Blue Bakery offers classic and designer flavored cupcakes, and customers can also custom order their cakes as well. Owner/cake artist Makenzie works with each client personally to create the cake of their dreams, and there are dozens of flavors to choose from: cinnamon sugar swirl, banana caramel, Irish car bomb, blueberry, lemon, espresso, and more!

A post shared by Aakanksha Agarwal (@aakanksha.a) on

Indiana Search
View more Indiana Bakeries and Pastry Shops.
Find Bakeries and Pastry Shops Near You
Select a Indiana town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Ohio County
Vanderburgh County